Major League Baseball History
All-Time



Links
Baseball-Reference Wikipedia Retrosheet Hall of Fame
MLB.com BR Bullpen Baseball Databank Negro Leagues
Baseball-Almanac SABR Baseball1 Seamheads
The Baseball Page SABR Bio Project Baseball-Fever MiLB

Top First Basemen by Decade
 
based on Wins Above Replacement
Position:
2010's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Miguel Cabrera
4
2010
2013
23.7
Joey Votto
4
2010
2013
22.0
Albert Pujols
4
2010
2013
18.4
Adrian Gonzalez
4
2010
2013
15.5
Prince Fielder
4
2010
2013
12.1
2000's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Albert Pujols
9
2001
2009
73.6
Todd Helton
10
2000
2009
53.0
Jason Giambi
10
2000
2009
38.8
Jim Thome
10
2000
2009
37.7
Mark Teixeira
7
2003
2009
36.6
1990's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Jeff Bagwell
9
1991
1999
56.6
Frank Thomas
10
1990
1999
52.7
Rafael Palmeiro
10
1990
1999
49.6
Mark McGwire
10
1990
1999
46.4
John Olerud
10
1990
1999
39.7
1980's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Eddie Murray
10
1980
1989
45.8
Keith Hernandez
10
1980
1989
43.0
Don Mattingly
8
1982
1989
33.3
Kent Hrbek
9
1981
1989
30.1
Darrell Evans
10
1980
1989
26.0
1970's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Tony Perez
10
1970
1979
36.1
Steve Garvey
10
1970
1979
29.4
George Scott
10
1970
1979
29.2
Bob Watson
10
1970
1979
26.0
Dick Allen
8
1970
1977
23.5
1960's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Harmon Killebrew
10
1960
1969
45.8
Willie McCovey
10
1960
1969
44.5
Norm Cash
10
1960
1969
43.0
Orlando Cepeda
10
1960
1969
37.8
Bill White
10
1960
1969
33.2
1950's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Gil Hodges
10
1950
1959
41.8
Ted Kluszewski
10
1950
1959
29.4
Earl Torgeson
10
1950
1959
25.2
Mickey Vernon
10
1950
1959
22.1
Joe Adcock
10
1950
1959
19.8
1940's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Johnny Mize
7
1940
1949
41.2
Phil Cavarretta
10
1940
1949
29.7
Frank McCormick
9
1940
1948
26.2
Elbie Fletcher
7
1940
1949
25.3
Rudy York
9
1940
1948
24.1
1930's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Lou Gehrig
10
1930
1939
73.1
Jimmie Foxx
10
1930
1939
72.9
Hank Greenberg
8
1930
1939
37.3
Bill Terry
7
1930
1936
36.4
Johnny Mize
4
1936
1939
26.2
1920's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Lou Gehrig
7
1923
1929
39.4
Joe Judge
10
1920
1929
31.8
George Sisler
9
1920
1929
31.3
Lu Blue
9
1921
1929
30.2
Jack Fournier
8
1920
1927
29.1
1910's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Ed Konetchy
10
1910
1919
31.9
Stuffy McInnis
10
1910
1919
30.0
Jake Daubert
10
1910
1919
29.0
George Sisler
5
1915
1919
25.6
Fred Merkle
10
1910
1919
20.5
1900's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Frank Chance
10
1900
1909
40.7
Harry Davis
9
1901
1909
33.9
Fred Tenney
10
1900
1909
29.9
Dan McGann
9
1900
1908
24.5
Charlie Hickman
9
1900
1908
22.3
1890's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Jake Beckley
10
1890
1899
34.5
Roger Connor
8
1890
1897
32.4
Dan Brouthers
7
1890
1896
28.4
Cap Anson
8
1890
1897
22.9
Jack Doyle
10
1890
1899
20.4
1880's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Roger Connor
10
1880
1889
51.8
Cap Anson
10
1880
1889
51.8
Dan Brouthers
10
1880
1889
50.4
Harry Stovey
10
1880
1889
34.7
Dave Orr
7
1883
1889
24.7
1870's
Player
Yrs
First
Last
WAR
Joe Start
9
1871
1879
15.0
Everett Mills
6
1871
1876
4.3
Herman Dehlman
6
1872
1877
2.9
Denny Mack
5
1871
1876
2.3
Tim Murnane
7
1872
1878
2.2
Any questions, comments, suggestions?? Please contact the webmaster at BaseballGauge@gmail.com

The statistics used were obtained free of charge from The Baseball Databank.

Wins Above Replacement data courtesy of Baseball-Reference.com.

Defensive Regression Analysis data used here was obtained with permission from Michael Humphreys, author of Wizardry.

The transaction and player splits data used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet.
Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at "www.retrosheet.org".

Uniform images used with permission from Marc Okkonen, author of Baseball Uniforms of the 20th Century.
Images can also be viewed at the Hall of Fame online exhibit Dressed to the Nines

Win Shares are calculated using the formula in the book Win Shares by Bill James