Baseball Hall of Fame
300 Hall of Famers
238 Players
20 Managers
32 Pioneer / Exec's
10 Umpires
Rules / Eligibility   Upcoming
BBWAA Rules 2013, 2014
Pre-Integration Era Rules 2013, 2016
Golden Era Rules 2014, 2017
Expansion Era Rules 2015, 2018
Links
Official Site MLB.com Baseball-Fever
Education Baseball-Almanac Wikipedia
HoFers ESPN BR Bullpen
Dressed to the Nines (Uniform Database)

The Pre-Integration Era

Positions
DQ

Players
1871-1946
     
1
Jim McCormick
SP
1878-1887
 
 
75.8
327.8
164.5
2
Bill Dahlen
SS
1891-1911
 
1.3 %
2
 
75.3
386.2
150.7
3
Tony Mullane
SP
1881-1894
 
 
67.8
390.7
216.1
4
Joe Jackson
LF
1908-1920
 
1.0 %
2
  BANg
62.4
287.2
179.8
5
Charlie Buffinton
SP
1882-1892
 
 
62.2
277.4
142.4
6
Wes Ferrell
SP
1927-1941
 
3.6 %
6
 
61.6
227.6
133.6
7
Jack Glasscock
SS
1879-1895
 
2.6 %
1
 
61.4
262.4
95.4
8
Tommy Bond
SP
1874-1884
 
1.3 %
1
 
61.0
303.6
164.6
9
Bob Caruthers
SP
1884-1893
 
 
60.6
339.6
208.6
10
Sherry Magee
LF
1904-1919
 
1.0 %
8
 
59.1
351.5
183.5
11
Urban Shocker
SP
1916-1928
 
1.5 %
5
 
58.7
220.2
122.7
12
Jack Quinn
SP
1909-1933
 
3.4 %
4
 
58.1
288.2
147.2
13
Eddie Cicotte
SP
1905-1920
 
  BANg
58.0
244.0
128.8
14
Bob Johnson
LF
1933-1945
 
0.8 %
2
 
57.1
286.4
137.4
15
Jack Powell
SP
1897-1912
 
 
56.8
286.4
131.6
16
George Uhle
SP
1919-1936
 
1.5 %
3
 
56.0
224.1
110.3
17
Jim Whitney
SP
1881-1890
 
 
55.7
273.4
133.8
18
Bobby Mathews
SP
1871-1887
 
 
55.0
327.8
140.7
19
Bucky Walters
SP
1931-1950
 
23.7 %
15
 
54.2
251.4
126.2
20
Wilbur Cooper
SP
1912-1926
 
4.4 %
9
 
53.7
259.1
138.1
21
Al Orth
SP
1895-1909
 
 
52.7
236.5
112.9
22
Stan Hack
3B
1932-1947
 
4.8 %
7
 
52.5
320.8
146.3
23
Babe Adams
SP
1906-1926
 
13.7 %
15
 
52.0
237.6
134.1
24
Silver King
SP
1886-1897
 
 
51.9
264.4
149.7
25
Ted Breitenstein
SP
1891-1901
 
0.5 %
1
 
51.5
214.7
109.0
26
Tommy Bridges
SP
1930-1946
 
7.5 %
7
 
51.1
225.4
126.3
27
Jack Stivetts
SP
1889-1899
 
 
50.9
277.0
171.0
28
Bob Elliott
3B
1939-1953
 
2.0 %
3
 
50.7
287.9
126.0
29
Dizzy Trout
SP
1939-1957
 
0.5 %
1
 
50.6
221.3
125.1
30
Carl Mays
SP
1915-1929
 
2.3 %
1
 
50.2
250.5
141.1
31
Eddie Rommel
SP
1920-1932
 
4.5 %
8
 
50.0
205.6
112.3
32
Jimmy Sheckard
LF
1897-1913
 
0.5 %
3
 
49.5
339.2
163.7
33
Jesse Tannehill
SP
1894-1911
 
0.5 %
2
 
48.7
228.4
125.0
34
Dutch Leonard
SP
1933-1953
 
1.8 %
7
 
48.6
234.5
119.2
35
Doc White
SP
1901-1913
 
 
48.5
228.6
116.0
36
Heinie Groh
3B
1912-1927
 
2.0 %
8
 
48.4
269.2
117.7
37
Larry Gardner
3B
1908-1924
 
 
48.2
259.6
93.2
38
Bobo Newsom
SP
1929-1953
 
9.4 %
13
 
48.2
239.2
106.5
39
Nap Rucker
SP
1907-1916
 
6.4 %
7
 
48.0
173.3
90.7
40
Bobby Veach
LF
1912-1925
 
0.5 %
1
 
47.7
266.6
123.6
41
George Mullin
SP
1902-1915
 
 
47.7
247.6
117.0
42
Dolf Luque
SP
1914-1935
 
5.6 %
9
 
47.6
238.0
124.0
43
Art Fletcher
SS
1909-1922
 
2.5 %
8
 
47.2
215.7
74.3
44
Lave Cross
3B
1887-1907
 
0.4 %
2
 
47.2
284.1
75.6
45
Buddy Myer
2B
1925-1941
 
0.7 %
1
 
46.9
257.0
88.0
46
Joe Judge
1B
1915-1934
 
5.6 %
7
 
46.9
263.9
106.1
47
Tommy Leach
3B
1898-1918
 
0.5 %
2
 
46.8
329.9
137.4
48
Bob Shawkey
SP
1913-1927
 
 
46.7
220.6
114.3
49
Hippo Vaughn
SP
1908-1921
 
 
46.3
203.4
109.3
50
Lon Warneke
SP
1930-1945
 
6.5 %
5
 
46.2
214.7
117.3



Managers
1871-1946
   
W
L
   
1
Charlie Grimm
1932-1960
 
1287
1067
.547
 
31.3
14.9
46.3
 
0
4
0
2
Jim Mutrie
1883-1891
 
658
419
.611
 
21.3
20.0
41.3
 
0
3
2
3
Steve O'Neill
1935-1954
 
1040
821
.559
 
27.0
7.5
34.5
 
0
1
1
4
Pat Moran
1915-1923
 
748
586
.561
 
19.6
12.5
32.1
 
0
2
1
5
Fielder Jones
1904-1918
 
683
582
.540
 
16.0
7.5
23.5
 
0
1
1
6
Bill Carrigan
1913-1929
 
489
500
.494
 
8.0
15.0
23.0
 
0
2
2
7
George Stallings
1897-1920
 
879
898
.495
 
14.4
7.5
21.9
 
0
1
1
8
Gabby Street
1929-1938
 
365
332
.524
 
7.7
12.5
20.2
 
0
2
1
9
Bill McGunnigle
1888-1896
 
327
248
.569
 
8.9
10.0
18.9
 
0
2
0
10
Jimmie Dykes
1934-1961
 
1406
1541
.477
 
18.7
0.0
18.7
 
0
0
0

Any questions, comments, suggestions?? Please contact the webmaster at BaseballGauge@gmail.com

The statistics used were obtained free of charge from The Baseball Databank.

Wins Above Replacement data courtesy of Baseball-Reference.com.

Defensive Regression Analysis data used here was obtained with permission from Michael Humphreys, author of Wizardry.

The transaction and player splits data used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet.
Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at "www.retrosheet.org".

Uniform images used with permission from Marc Okkonen, author of Baseball Uniforms of the 20th Century.
Images can also be viewed at the Hall of Fame online exhibit Dressed to the Nines

Win Shares are calculated using the formula in the book Win Shares by Bill James